Kalorika Open in Telegram

Why your weight jumps from day to day and how to read the weight line

Published 2 min read

A single weigh-in picks up water, salt and last night's dinner. How to look at your weight so you can see where it's really going.

You step on the scale and you’re a kilo up overnight. Fat doesn’t appear that fast: to gain a kilogram of fat you’d have to overeat by roughly 7,700 kcal. So the scale is showing you something else.

What the scale really shows

A scale weighs everything at once: fat, muscle, water, the food in your stomach. Over a single day, water changes the most.

  • A salty dinner makes you retain water — you’re up in the morning.
  • A lot of carbs in the evening — up again: your muscles store water along with them.
  • A hard workout — up for a day or two while your muscles recover.
  • For women, weight shifts noticeably over the cycle.

None of that is fat. That’s why a single weigh-in tells you almost nothing.

Look at the line, not the dot

It’s more useful to look at the smoothed line — the average over the last few days. It doesn’t jerk after one dinner, and it shows the direction. If the line is going down and today’s dot is above yesterday’s, everything is fine.

In Kalorika the line appears on the analytics screen by itself once you have a few weigh-ins. Next to it you can see the pace: how much you’re losing a week.

How to weigh yourself so the numbers are comparable

  • In the morning, after the toilet, before you eat or drink.
  • On the same scale, on a hard floor.
  • Often. Three or four times a week gives you a line; once a week gives you a lottery.
  • Log the number you don’t like, too. Skipping a “bad” day makes the line prettier and less useful.

How long to wait

Two weeks is the minimum for the line to mean anything. Before that, any conclusion — “I’m not losing weight”, “it’s all pointless” — is based on random fluctuations. After two or three weeks you can see whether what you’re doing works, and then it makes sense to change something.

When to stop

If weighing yourself ruins your day, or you can’t get the number out of your head, weigh yourself less often or not at all — a food diary works without a scale. And if your weight changes fast for no obvious reason, that’s a question for a doctor, not for an app.

Sources

The studies and reviews behind the numbers in this article.

  1. Hall (2008). What is the required energy deficit per unit weight loss?. International Journal of Obesity.
  2. Olsson & Saltin (1970). Variation in total body water with muscle glycogen changes in man. Acta Physiologica Scandinavica.
  3. Steinberg et al. (2015). Weighing every day matters: daily weighing improves weight loss and adoption of weight control behaviors. Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics.

What to do next

Try it yourself

Kalorika counts your day’s calories from a photo, a few words or a barcode. The Telegram bot works today, and it is free.

Open in Telegram

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first.

Leave a comment

Rules
  • A comment appears after it is checked, under the name you gave.
  • No insults, no advertising, no links, no personal data of other people.
  • This is not a place for medical advice: we will not publish a diagnosis or a prescription.
  • Your e-mail is not shown; it is used to find and delete the comment at your request. An answer from the team appears on the page, not in your mail.