One table gives buckwheat 330 kcal per 100 g, another gives it 92. Both numbers are right: the first is for dry grain, the second for cooked. The mistake starts when you take the weight from one and the calories from the other. Then your entry is three or four times out.
Why the numbers differ
Cooking doesn’t make calories disappear or appear. The weight changes: grain soaks up water, and 100 g of dry buckwheat turns into about 360 g cooked. There are as many calories in the pot as before, but now they are spread over more weight — so there are fewer per 100 g.
Meat goes the other way: when you fry or boil it, it loses water and gets lighter, so there are more calories per 100 g. Food composition databases count cooked dishes exactly like that — by the weight after cooking, not by the sum of the raw ingredients.
Dry and cooked: a table
The numbers are from the Kalorika table, per 100 g.
| Food | Dry / raw | Cooked | How many times heavier |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buckwheat | 330 | 92 (boiled) | ≈ 3.6 |
| White rice | 344 | 116 (boiled) | ≈ 3 |
| Pasta | 344 | 112 (boiled) | ≈ 3 |
| Bulgur | 342 | 83 (boiled) | ≈ 4 |
| Lentils | 295 | 111 (boiled) | ≈ 2.7 |
| Rolled oats | 366 | 88 (porridge made with water) | ≈ 4 |
| Chicken breast | 113 (raw) | 137 (boiled), 164 (fried) | gets about a fifth lighter |
How much water the grain soaks up depends on how you cook it: fluffy grains weigh less, mushy ones more. So the cooked number is an average, and the dry one is exact.
Two mistakes that put you three times out
An example: you take 70 g of dry buckwheat, cook it and end up with about 250 g. That holds about 231 kcal.
- Cooked weight, dry number. 250 g × 330 kcal = 825 kcal. That’s 3.6 times too high — the day looks like a disaster when everything is fine.
- Dry weight, cooked number. 70 g × 92 kcal = 64 kcal. That’s 3.6 times too low — and then you can’t work out why your weight isn’t moving.
There is one rule: the weight and the number have to describe the same state. If you weighed the dry grain, take the “dry” line. If you weighed the cooked buckwheat on your plate, take “boiled”.
What’s easier to weigh
- Cooking just for yourself — weigh it dry. The dry weight doesn’t depend on how much water you added or how long it boiled, so it’s more accurate.
- Cooking a pot for the family — weigh your plate and take the cooked number. You can’t split the dry weight between everyone anyway.
- Cooking for several days — you can work out your batch once: dry weight × dry calories ÷ cooked weight × 100. How to do this for any dish is in the article on home-cooked dishes.
Pelmeni: raw, boiled, fried
Pelmeni (meat dumplings) work the same way, only not the way you’d expect. Pelmeni made to the recipe on our pelmeni page are about 219 kcal per 100 g raw and 199 boiled: the dough soaks up water as they cook, and the pelmeni get about a tenth heavier.
- On the pack there’s usually the number for raw, frozen pelmeni. Use it if you weigh them before cooking.
- Boiled, on your plate — take “pelmeni, boiled”. One is about 13 g, so 20 of them are about 260 g and about 520 kcal.
- Fried — that’s boiled or raw pelmeni plus oil. A tablespoon of oil is about 150 kcal. Some of it stays in the pan, but a good part soaks into the dough, so it’s worth logging the oil separately.
Sour cream with your pelmeni is a separate entry too.
How Kalorika does it
In the Kalorika table dry and cooked are separate rows, and the name always says which it is: “buckwheat, dry”, “buckwheat, boiled”. If you just write “buckwheat 200 g”, Kalorika takes cooked by default: that’s how people usually eat it. If you weighed it dry, add the word: “dry buckwheat 70 g”. For a pack of pelmeni the easiest thing is to scan the barcode — then the number is the one printed on the pack.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.